Intellectual Rights Infringement in the 21st Century

Contributor: Jesutofunmi Idowu

INTRODUCTION

Intellectual property rights (IPRs) are legal protections granted to the creators and owners of original works, inventions, and innovations. These rights cover a wide array of creations, including inventions, designs, trademarks, artistic works, and trade secrets. The production, dissemination, and consumption of intellectual property have undergone significant change in this 21st century, which is fueled by the internet and contemporary technology. This innovation has birthed new intellectual rights which is crucial to fostering innovation and creativity across various industries.^[1]

However, with the rapid advancement of technology and the growth of the digital world, intellectual rights infringement has become a pervasive issue in the 21st century. The widespread availability of digital tools, the internet, and global connectivity has made it easier for individuals and organizations to copy, distribute, and profit from intellectual property without proper authorization.^[2]

In Nigeria, there is an alarming expansion of the types of products being infringed, items such as clothing and designs, pharmaceutical and medical products, fast food and drink, and automotive parts, are being cloned. To check these activities various laws such as Copyright Act,^[3] Trademark Act,^[4] Patent and Design Act^[5] and Institutional framework like Copyright Commission are put in place.

The purpose of this discussion is to explore the complexities of intellectual rights infringement in the 21^st century, examining the various types of infringements, the factors that contribute to their rise, and the global challenges faced in protecting intellectual property. It will also delve into the economic and legal consequences of IP violations, alongside potential technological and policy solutions. Understanding these issues is vital for governments, businesses, and individuals to navigate the evolving space of intellectual property protection and ensure the continued advancement of innovation and creativity in the 21st century.

TYPES OF INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS

Intellectual rights are diverse legal protections that cover a range of creations and innovations, ensuring that creators have exclusive rights to their work. These rights include copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, and industrial designs, each providing different protections based on the nature of the intellectual property.

1. Copyright: Copyright protects original works of authorship, such as literary, musical, and artistic creations. It grants the creator exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, and perform their work.^[6]
2. Trademark: Trademarks are signs, symbols or words used to distinguish goods or services in the marketplace. They help protect brand identity and prevent confusion among consumers.
3. Patent: A patent grants exclusive rights to inventors for a new invention or process, typically for a set period. It prevents others from making, using, or selling the invention without permission.
4. Trade Secrets: Trade secrets refer to confidential business information, such as formulas, practices, or designs, that provide a competitive edge. Protection is maintained through confidentiality agreements and internal security measures.
5. Industrial Designs: Industrial designs protect the aesthetic appearance of products, including their shape, colour, or surface decoration. They are essential for preserving the unique visual identity of manufactured items.

FORMS OF INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS INFRINGEMENT

Intellectual rights infringement refers to the unauthorized use or violation of protected intellectual property. These infringements not only harm the creators and owners but also undermine the overall value of intellectual property rights, some of which include:

1. Copyright Infringement: Copyright infringement occurs when someone reproduces, distributes, performs, or publicly displays a copyrighted work without permission from the copyright holder. This often includes unauthorized copying of books, music, software, films, and digital content, usually for commercial gain.
2. Patent Infringement: Patent infringement happens when someone makes, uses, sells, or distributes a patented invention without the consent of the patent holder. This often occurs in technological and pharmaceutical industries like, where the unauthorized use of patented processes or products can result in substantial financial losses for inventors.
3. Trademark Counterfeiting: Trademark counterfeiting involves producing and selling goods that bear a registered trademark without authorization, intending to deceive consumers into believing they are legitimate.
4. Software Piracy: Software piracy is the unauthorized duplication, distribution, or use of software applications. This includes illegal downloading, sharing cracked versions, or using pirated software in commercial environments, causing financial loss to software developers and undermining the integrity of the software market.
5. Online Piracy and Illegal Distribution: Online piracy involves the illegal distribution of copyrighted digital content such as movies, music, software, and books over the Internet. This is typically done through file-sharing platforms or torrent sites, where unauthorized copies are made available for free, leading to significant revenue loss for content creators.
6. Plagiarism: Plagiarism is the act of using someone else’s work or ideas without proper attribution, presenting them as one’s own. This can occur in academic, literary, and professional contexts and is a violation of copyright law, as well as ethical standards in many fields.

FACTORS DRIVING INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS INFRINGEMENT

Several key factors contribute to the rise of IPR infringement, including the growth of the internet, the lack of awareness of intellectual rights, and the challenges posed by new technologies. Understanding these factors is essential for developing effective strategies to prevent infringement and protect intellectual property.

1. Digital Transformation and the Internet: The Internet has made it easier than ever for individuals to access, copy, and distribute intellectual property without authorization. Digital content, such as music, movies, and software, can be shared globally in seconds, often bypassing legal protections and enforcement mechanisms.
2. Globalization and Cross-Border Issues: As businesses expand internationally, intellectual property violations have become more complex to address. Different countries have varying laws and enforcement standards, making it difficult to regulate and prosecute infringement across borders, especially in regions with weaker IPR protections.
3. Lack of Awareness and Enforcement: Many consumers and even creators are unaware of intellectual property rights, leading to unintentional infringement. Additionally, enforcement mechanisms can be slow or ineffective, especially in the digital space, where pirated content can proliferate rapidly without swift legal recourse.
4. Evolving Technologies (AI, Blockchain, etc.): New technologies, such as artificial intelligence and blockchain, create both opportunities and challenges for intellectual property protection. AI can be used to replicate creative works, while blockchain offers potential solutions for tracking and protecting digital content, but it also raises new questions about ownership and rights enforcement in a decentralized environment.^[7]

CONSEQUENCES OF INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS INFRINGEMENT

Intellectual rights infringement has significant consequences that affect not only the creators and businesses but also the broader economy and society. These violations can lead to substantial financial losses, legal ramifications, and a diminished sense of innovation.

1. Economic Impact on Creators and Industries: Intellectual property infringement can result in severe financial losses for creators, businesses, and entire industries. Unauthorized reproduction or sale of a product means creators miss out on royalties, licensing fees, and sales, hindering their ability to reinvest in future innovations.
2. Legal Repercussions: Those found guilty of intellectual property infringement can face legal actions, including lawsuits, fines, and penalties. These legal battles can be time-consuming and costly, even if the infringer ultimately loses.
3. Loss of Innovation and Creativity: Intellectual rights infringement discourages innovation by eroding the incentives for creators to develop new ideas. When creators and companies cannot protect their work, they may be less willing to invest time and resources into research and development.
4. Impact on Brand Reputation and Consumer Trust: For businesses, intellectual property infringement, particularly in cases of counterfeiting and trademark violations, can damage brand reputation. Consumers may lose trust in a brand if they unknowingly purchase counterfeit goods or experience substandard products.

GLOBAL CHALLENGES IN ADDRESSING INFRINGEMENT

As IP infringement increasingly occurs across borders, particularly in the digital space, international cooperation becomes essential to combat these issues. However, legal inconsistencies, jurisdictional conflicts, and emerging technologies complicate efforts to create a cohesive global solution to protect intellectual property rights.

1. Jurisdictional Issues: One of the biggest challenges in addressing IP infringement is the lack of a uniform legal framework across countries. Each nation has its own set of intellectual property laws, enforcement procedures, and penalties, which can lead to conflicting legal interpretations and protection levels. This inconsistency makes it difficult to prosecute infringers who operate in multiple jurisdictions, particularly when an infringing party operates from a country with weak IP laws or enforcement mechanisms.^[8]
2. Enforcement Challenges in the Digital Age: The rapid growth of the internet and digital technologies has dramatically increased the potential for IP infringement, with content being easily copied, shared, and distributed online. However, tracking and enforcing intellectual property rights in the digital realm is challenging. The anonymity provided by the internet allows infringers to operate covertly, often across borders, making it difficult for IP holders to identify and take action against violators in real-time.
3. Role of International Organizations: While international organizations like the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the World Trade Organization (WTO) play a role in creating global standards for IP protection, their influence is limited by the voluntary adherence of member countries. Some countries may resist stricter IP enforcement due to concerns over national sovereignty or economic interests, further hindering the implementation of consistent global policies.
4. Emerging Technologies and Their Impact: New technologies, such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and digital media, are transforming the way intellectual property is created, distributed, and protected. However, these innovations present unique challenges for IP law, as they raise questions about ownership, rights enforcement, and digital reproduction that current legal frameworks may not fully address. The rapid pace of technological advancement often outpaces the development of appropriate legal solutions to safeguard intellectual property.

LEGAL AND POLICY FRAMEWORKS

In addressing intellectual rights infringement, both national laws and international treaties play a crucial role in shaping how IP is protected and enforced. In Nigeria, national laws are structured to address IP protection, while international treaties attempt to harmonize IP enforcement across borders. However, updating IP laws to reflect digital advancements remains a challenge, requiring constant adaptation and global cooperation.

1. Nigeria National Laws and Regulations

In Nigeria intellectual property is primarily governed by the Nigerian Copyright Act 2022, the Patents and Designs Act 1970, and the Trade Marks Act. These laws provide a legal framework for protecting copyrights, patents, trademarks, and industrial designs within the country. Additionally, the Nigerian Copyright Commission (NCC), National Agency for Food Drug and Administration and Control (NAFDAC), Standard Organization of Nigeria (SON), and Trademark Registry all work to enforce copyright protections and combat piracy.

Specifically, the Copyright Act grants copyright holders the exclusive right to make their works available to the public via wire, wireless or online means in such a way that members of the public can access the work from a place and at a time individually chosen by them.^[9] The Act protects copyrighted works from online threats by expressly providing that no person shall knowingly circumvent by avoiding, bypassing, removing, deactivating, decrypting or otherwise impairing a technological protection measure that effectively protects a copyrighted work. ^[10]

Additionally, the Act also empowers copyright holders to issue a notice of infringement in writing to relevant Internet Service Providers requesting a takedown or deactivation of a link to any infringing content hosted on its systems or network. Sequel to notifying the subscriber responsible for the infringement, the service provider is obliged to take down the infringing content after 48 hours of the notice.^[11] The service provider is also mandated to notify the Nigerian Copyright Commission (the “Commission”) of such takedown. Further, the Act empowers the Commission (by itself or with the assistance of any other person) to block or disable access to any content, link or website hosted on a system or network, which it reasonably believes to infringe copyright.

In the event of an online breach of copyright, the Act provides liabilities to the tune of One Million Naira (N1,000,000) only or a term of imprisonment not less than 5 (five) years or liability to both a fine and a term of imprisonment for anyone convicted.^[12]

1. International Agreements and Treaties

Nigeria, like many other countries, is a signatory to several international treaties aimed at strengthening intellectual property protection globally. Key agreements include the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) treaties. These treaties establish baseline standards for IP protection and ensure that Nigerian creators can protect their work in member countries. Furthermore, Nigeria is a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO) and adheres to the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS). These international frameworks help Nigeria align its domestic laws with global IP standards, fostering a more consistent approach to IP protection.

Updating IP Laws in Light of Digital Explosion

In the digital era, the ease of copying, distributing, and reproducing intellectual property online presents new challenges that current IP laws may not adequately address. For example, the rise of digital content, including music, films, software, and literature, has led to widespread piracy and copyright infringement across the internet.

While Nigeria’s IP laws provide a foundation for protection, they struggle to keep pace with the rapid growth of digital platforms and the global nature of internet-based infringement. The challenge lies in updating laws to account for new technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and cloud computing, which raise questions about digital ownership and enforcement.

Additionally, current enforcement mechanisms often fall short in the face of complex digital piracy, where infringing content can quickly go viral and spread internationally. There is a need for continual reform of national IP laws to address these gaps and ensure that they remain effective in the digital age.

TECHNOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS AND INNOVATIONS

As the digital landscape expands and intellectual property violations become more sophisticated, leveraging technology becomes essential to protect and enforce IPRs. Innovations such as digital rights management (DRM), blockchain, artificial intelligence (AI), and machine learning offer promising solutions to track and prevent IP violations. These technologies not only enhance the ability to protect IP but also create new ways to monitor and enforce IP rights in an increasingly complex digital environment.

1. Digital Rights Management (DRM): DRM refers to technologies used to control access to copyrighted digital content and prevent unauthorized distribution. DRM solutions allow creators and businesses to set restrictions on how their content is used, such as preventing copying, printing, or redistributing digital files like music, videos, and software. By embedding encryption or other protective features in digital files, DRM helps ensure that only authorized users can access or modify the content.^[13]
2. Blockchain for IP Protection: Blockchain technology, known for its decentralized and secure nature, offers an innovative way to protect intellectual property. By recording transactions and ownership rights on an immutable ledger, blockchain ensures that intellectual property is traceable, transparent, and difficult to alter or counterfeit. This technology can be particularly useful for tracking the provenance of digital assets, such as art, music, and patents, ensuring that creators retain control over their works. Blockchain can also streamline licensing processes and facilitate smart contracts that automatically enforce IP terms, improving efficiency and reducing the need for intermediaries.
3. Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning: AI algorithms can analyse large amounts of digital content and identify instances of infringement by comparing newly uploaded material to a database of existing copyrighted works. For example, AI-powered image recognition tools can detect unauthorized use of copyrighted images online, while music recognition technologies like Shazam can identify pirated songs. Machine learning models can also predict patterns of infringement, helping rights holders proactively protect their content.^[14]
4. Online Anti-Piracy Technologies: In response to the rapid rise of online piracy, various anti-piracy technologies have been developed to track, monitor, and remove infringing content from digital platforms. These include content identification systems, like YouTube’s Content ID, which automatically scans uploaded videos for copyrighted material and removes or monetizes infringing content. Similar technologies are used by streaming services, software developers, and online marketplaces to identify counterfeit goods and prevent the sale or distribution of pirated content. These systems rely on digital fingerprinting, hashing, and watermarking techniques to uniquely identify legitimate content, helping to enforce IP rights across the internet.^[15]

In summary, technological innovations provide powerful tools for protecting intellectual property in the 21^st century. However, while these solutions are making progress in addressing IP infringement, they must be continuously adapted to meet the evolving nature of digital piracy and infringement methods. Combining technological tools with strong legal frameworks and international cooperation will be essential to ensuring the effective protection of intellectual property globally.

STRATEGIES FOR PROTECTING INTELLECTUAL RIGHTS

As intellectual property (IP) becomes increasingly vulnerable to misuse in the digital age, effective protection strategies are essential for ensuring that creators, businesses, and innovators can benefit from their inventions and ideas. These strategies encompass legal protections, awareness campaigns, enforcement mechanisms, and technological innovations that together create a robust defence against infringement.

1. Legal Protections and Registration: One of the primary strategies for protecting intellectual rights is ensuring that works are legally registered and protected under national and international laws. In many countries, including Nigeria, registering intellectual property with the relevant authorities, such as the Nigerian Copyright Commission (NCC) or the Nigerian Industrial Property Office (NIPO), is crucial for gaining legal recognition and exclusive rights over a creation. Registration provides a public record of ownership, which is vital when seeking to enforce rights in court or when pursuing legal action against infringers. Additionally, creators should take advantage of international agreements like the Berne Convention and the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) to ensure that their intellectual property is protected globally, especially in key markets.
2. Proactive Monitoring and Enforcement: Another essential strategy for protecting intellectual rights is proactive monitoring of the market and digital platforms for potential infringements. This involves using monitoring tools and services to track the use of copyrighted works, trademarks, or patents across various online platforms, including e-commerce sites, social media, and file-sharing networks.
3. Technological Solutions and Innovation: In the digital age, technology plays an increasingly important role in protecting intellectual property. As online piracy and counterfeit goods proliferate, implementing technological solutions such as Digital Rights Management (DRM), watermarking, and blockchain can help protect digital content and prevent unauthorized access, duplication, and distribution. DRM technologies, for instance, allow content creators to control how their digital works are used, ensuring that only authorized users can access or share them.
4. Collaboration and International Cooperation: Protecting intellectual property on a global scale requires international collaboration and adherence to global treaties and conventions. Since infringement often occurs across borders, creators need to leverage international agreements like the Berne Convention, TRIPS, and the WIPO Copyright Treaty to ensure that their intellectual property is protected beyond national borders. Strong partnerships with other countries’ IP enforcement agencies, trade organizations, and law enforcement can help curb piracy and counterfeit activities.
5. Enforcement of IP in the Digital Marketplace: With the rise of e-commerce, social media, and digital content-sharing platforms, protecting intellectual rights in the digital marketplace has become increasingly important. Platforms such as Amazon, YouTube, and Facebook have established IP protection tools, such as the Content ID system on YouTube and the Amazon Brand Registry, which allow rights holders to identify and take down infringing content. Businesses should actively engage with these platforms to monitor their intellectual property and use the available tools to report and remove counterfeit or pirated products.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the protection of intellectual rights is more critical than ever in the 21st century, as technological advancements and globalization continue to shape the way intellectual property is created, shared, and consumed. While national laws and international agreements provide a foundational framework for IP protection, challenges such as digital piracy, cross-border infringements, and the rapid pace of technological innovation highlight the need for constant adaptation and innovation in both legal and enforcement mechanisms. By leveraging a combination of legal protections, technological solutions, strategic partnerships, and international cooperation, creators and businesses can better safeguard their intellectual property. As the digital landscape evolves, both policymakers and innovators must work together to ensure that intellectual rights are respected, enforced, and continuously updated to meet the demands of an increasingly interconnected world. Ultimately, strong protection of intellectual property fosters creativity, innovation, and economic growth, benefiting individuals, industries, and societies globally.

1. World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). About IP. Available at https://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/ accessed on 2^nd December 2024. ↑
2. Global Intellectual Property convention. Intellectual Property in the Digital Age. Available at https://www.globalipconvention.com/blog/intellectual-property-challenges-in-the-digital-age accessed on 2^nd December 2024. ↑
3. Copyright Act 2022 ↑
4. T13 LFN 2004. ↑
5. P2 LFN 2004. ↑
6. Section 2 Copyright Act ↑
7. Uti Asikin et al. (2023) Intellectual Property Rights in the Use of Blockchain Technology from a Contemporary Islamic Legal Perspective. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Innovations 3(6): 981-997 Available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/376997768_Intellectual_Property_Rights_in_the_Use_of_Blockchain_Technology_From_A_Contemporary_Islamic_Legal_Perspective accessed on 4th December 2024 ↑
8. Templars. The Challenges of Protecting Intellectual Property Rights in Nigeria in the Age of Social Media. Available at https://www.templars-law.com/app/uploads/2023/05/03052023-THE-CHALLENGES-OF-PROTECTING-INTELLECTUAL-PROPERTY-RIGHTS-IN-NIGERIA_.pdf accessed on 4th December 2024. ↑
9. Section 6-9 & 38 Copyright Act. ↑
10. Section 26 Copyright Act. ↑
11. Section 29 & 30 Copyright Act. ↑
12. Section 20 (7) Copyright Act. ↑
13. Mir Mohammad Azad et al. (2010) Digital Rights Management. International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security 10(11): 24-33 Available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321070621_Digital_Rights_Management accessed on 4th December 2024 ↑
14. Yotam Werzansky-Orland (2024). AI-Generated Content and the Question of Copyright. International Journal of Business. 5. 1-20. Avaliable at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381566789_AI-Generated_Content_and_the_Question_of_Copyright accessed on 4th December. ↑
15. Pratyush Prakarsh at el. (2024) Intellectual Property Law in the Age of Digital Piracy and Artificial Intelligence. International Journal of Law Management & Hummanities 7(5): 1566-1625 Available at https://ijlmh.com/wp-content/uploads/Intellectual-Property-Law-in-the-Age-of-Digital-Piracy-and-Artificial-Intelligence.pdf accessed on 4th December. ↑